Built Different.

Discover the place you’ll call home, guided by people who know your neighborhood best.

Sell

Cara Huffman

REALTOR®/Broker

FacebookLinkedIn
Phone
Phone: (765) 524-2037
Additional phone
Additional Phone: (765) 521-9464
Languages
Languages: English
Email Me

About Me

Cara Huffman is a lifelong resident of Henry County and began her career in real estate in 2004 when she began working in residential property management. She graduated in 2007 with a bachelors degree in Residential Property Management from Ball State University. After managing multifamily housing for several years in Indianapolis, Cara then earned her real estate brokers license in 2012 and is enjoying her true passion, which is real estate and being involved in her community. Cara is a Broker/Owner of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate and is a Board Member of the New Caslte Henry County Economic Development Corporation, New Castle Henry County Chamber of Commerce, Mid Eastern Association of Realtors, Tri Kappa Alpha Tau, and is a member of Foursquare Gospel Church. Cara and her husband, Matt Huffman, enjoy their life on their small farm with their three boys Braedon, Cain, and Bane. As a family, they enjoy horseback riding, boating, camping, and spending time together. 

What Is Your Home Worth?

Find the market value of your home compared to other homes in your area for FREE!

Client Testimonials

Cara helped us get our first house and was extremely helpful and personal. We definitely recommend h...

Holly B

Cara was very professional, friendly, knowledgeable, and hardworking. Her work ethic and response time is outstanding.

Kim

Cara is extremely knowledgeable in both buying and selling. We have bought and sold through her and I can honestly say I wouldn't use another agent for either process.

Urlage

Selling our home of almost 20 yrs. was a daunting thought. Cara was able to address all our concerns...

Pelfrey

Cara is a knowledgable and professional real estate agent. She was a pleasure to work with. We highly recommend and we have referred several people to her.

Mike

Cara is an expert when it comes to her knowledge in Real Estate Property's. She really shows her passion in her hard work she provides to her clients.

Crabtree

My dad began having some health issues and needed to move from his home of many years into independent living.

Ricci

Cara did a very thorough explanation of what was going on and what to expect at each step of the selling process.

Cross

Cara was very helpful in selling our property and knows the market regarding the area and value of properties.

Wantz

Cara Taylor was amazing in helping us find a home that fit both our lifestyle and our budget. She showed us many homes in the New Castle area, not giving up until we found the right home for us.

Stroup

We put our house up for sale and with her help it sold within 2 weeks! We had rented the house for 3 1/2 years and then had someone recommended by Cara to fix it up so it could be put on the market.

O'harra

Our house was on the market 3 days when Cara called and said we had as bid and we sold our home. With Cara's help staging and knowledge on pricing we were so happy Cara Taylor was our agent.

Marcy

Cara was exceptional, guided me though the entire process, answered any questions, gave great suggestions and we closed the deal very quickly.

Denney

I was a recent widow needing to downsize. Cara was recommended by my neighbors who had just sold their home with her assistance.

Horan

Cara helped us get our first house and was extremely helpful and personal. We definitely recommend h...

Holly B

Cara was very professional, friendly, knowledgeable, and hardworking. Her work ethic and response time is outstanding.

Kim

Cara is extremely knowledgeable in both buying and selling. We have bought and sold through her and I can honestly say I wouldn't use another agent for either process.

Urlage

Selling our home of almost 20 yrs. was a daunting thought. Cara was able to address all our concerns...

Pelfrey

Cara is a knowledgable and professional real estate agent. She was a pleasure to work with. We highly recommend and we have referred several people to her.

Mike

Cara is an expert when it comes to her knowledge in Real Estate Property's. She really shows her passion in her hard work she provides to her clients.

Crabtree

My dad began having some health issues and needed to move from his home of many years into independent living.

Ricci

Cara did a very thorough explanation of what was going on and what to expect at each step of the selling process.

Cross

Cara was very helpful in selling our property and knows the market regarding the area and value of properties.

Wantz

Cara Taylor was amazing in helping us find a home that fit both our lifestyle and our budget. She showed us many homes in the New Castle area, not giving up until we found the right home for us.

Stroup

We put our house up for sale and with her help it sold within 2 weeks! We had rented the house for 3 1/2 years and then had someone recommended by Cara to fix it up so it could be put on the market.

O'harra

Our house was on the market 3 days when Cara called and said we had as bid and we sold our home. With Cara's help staging and knowledge on pricing we were so happy Cara Taylor was our agent.

Marcy

Cara was exceptional, guided me though the entire process, answered any questions, gave great suggestions and we closed the deal very quickly.

Denney

I was a recent widow needing to downsize. Cara was recommended by my neighbors who had just sold their home with her assistance.

Horan

Latest Blogs

Stay informed with our real estate blogs—your go-to resource for market insights, tips, and trends.

Indy Fireworks Guide: The Best Neighborhoods for Summer Celebrations

Indy Fireworks Guide: The Best Neighborhoods for Summer Celebrations

Jul 2, 2026

Read More Arrow
Why Everyone Is Talking About Carmel and Fishers

Why Everyone Is Talking About Carmel and Fishers

Jun 29, 2026

Read More Arrow
Moving Before the Bell Rings: A Family Guide to Buying a Home Before Fall

Moving Before the Bell Rings: A Family Guide to Buying a Home Before Fall

Jun 24, 2026

Read More Arrow
Boost Your Home’s First Impression This Summer Without Breaking the Bank

Boost Your Home’s First Impression This Summer Without Breaking the Bank

Jun 22, 2026

Read More Arrow
F.C. Tucker Agents and Teams Named Among Nation’s Top 1.5% by RealTrends

F.C. Tucker Agents and Teams Named Among Nation’s Top 1.5% by RealTrends

Jun 19, 2026

Read More Arrow

Download the App

Take classes on the go with the just home app. Stream or download to watch on the plane, the subway, or wherever you learn best.